In a shocking twist, police have revealed that the formal inquest into the murder of 17-year-old altar girl, Carly Isaacs, was deemed undetected, while gender-based activists have called for a fresh investigation into evidence as there was no forced entry to the teenager’s home.
The slain Mitchell’s Plain teenager’s family has since said they will ask to speak with the area’s station commander to discuss why the case has remained cold for five years without an arrest or a suspect being detained.
Three years ago, police said the matter would be referred for an inquest.
But in its latest response to the case, the police’s spokesperson Wesley Twigg said: “Be advised that the investigating officer followed all avenues and leads in order to make a breakthrough in the case. The matter was referred to the inquest court and was referred to as undetected. We appeal to anyone with any information who can shed light on the incident to contact the investigating officer Warrant Officer Fillis on 079 894 1510 or 021 370 1737.”
Police did not detail why the matter remained undetected.
Isaacs was killed inside her own home while her father was reportedly asleep in the same house.
There were no signs of forced entry, raising serious concerns about how the perpetrator gained access and carried out the crime without detection.
These unanswered questions remain a source of frustration for the family and the community, who are calling for a re-examination of the available evidence.
Gender-based activist, Siya Monakali, of Ilitha Labantu, said they were deeply concerned about the ongoing lack of justice in the case.
“The lack of urgency and transparency from the relevant authorities reflects a broader failure in the justice system, particularly in cases involving violence against young women and children. The delay in securing justice for Carly sends a disheartening message to families and survivors across the country who place their trust in law enforcement for protection and redress," said Monakali.
Isaacs’s mother, Anthea Isaacs, upon receiving the news about the inquest, said she would be requesting a meeting to see the station commander.
Cape Argus